Once you have purchased your tomatoes and let them ripen for a few days, it is sauce day! This is a very exciting day of the year to me – it starts early in the morning and goes through most of they day. It is a day of tradition, family and a few beer or glasses of wine (though be cautious – 300 pounds of molten tomato does have an element of danger after all).
We start by washing the tomatoes in large buckets and then we slice each one lengthwise. There are a lot of people who skip this step and put the whole tomatoes directly into the tomato press. We cut them to look for hidden rot and deep bruising that you may miss if examining only the surface. We generally find less then 12 tomatoes like this a year (from 6-8 bushels).

We are spoiled with a motorized press. My father used to have a manual (hand crank) press and the work was quadruple. He later added a furnace motor to it to semi-automate the process (this contraption also liked to spit tomatoes over everything as it consumed them). We later moved to a motorized press (our model was around $450 divided by two families). We now process twice the amount of tomatoes in half the time that we used to.
The process is simple – tomato halves are loaded into the funnel at the top of the mill and crushed within the machine. Seeds and skins are expelled into one bucket and sauce into another.

Now a few tips and things to think about:
- The initial colour is odd. Expect a funny pinkish hue – when the tomatoes begin to react to the heat an odd foam will appear. This is normal – the cooking process will turn it a deeper red and the foam will reduce.

- The seeds and skins can be put through the mill several times to extract more sauce. We wait until we have a large quantity of discard before we stop the machine before adding all the skins to the top. As they go through the machine, I place my hand at the place where the skins are expelled. Be careful not to reach in (the screw and press is very close to the end). I let my hand fill before gently plugging the end of the press until a small bit of pressure pushes back on my hands. This allows me to pull an entire plug of seed and skin to be processed again. I repeat this several times.


- Add the sauce to your pan as you go and ensure the heat is on. Best results come from heating the sauce as soon as possible and it is best to heat as you go and add fresh pulp to heated sauce (you are not trying to bring it to a rapid boil but want a gentle simmer). This will help prevent separation.
- Bees and wasps love the smell of the harvest. A windy day is great if you are fortunate enough to choose. Bee or wasp traps are a close second.
- We love setting up under an overhang – a sudden change of weather would create havoc if rain decided to join your day of preserving.

- This is a task that you want to share with others. It is a lot of work and creating any significant quantity would be hard alone. We find that 4 people is best for our needs. This also makes the expense of a press far more bearable. A $500 press could easily be shared between 2-4 sets of 4 people as long as they don’t prepare their tomatoes on the same day. It takes us about 30 minutes a bushel to transform tomatoes to pulp (it was closer to 50 minutes at the start).

- Wear gloves. It has taken me 3 years of learning this lesson the hard way before finally getting wise to this. The acid in the tomatoes will eat your skin and it can be very painful. Tomato water will keep your fingers wet for hours and your skin will soften before giving in to a slow burn. It is just not worth the pain.

Tune in tomorrow for tips on cooking the sauce down!




[...] Crush your friends [...]
[...] The Crush A walk-through of our crushing process including an overview of the equipment and setup we`ve accumulated over 10+ years of making tomato sauce. The most important piece of equipment remains the protective gloves (something I stubbornly refused for years). [...]
I just love reading here – you explain everything so well and the photos are VERY helpful and well done.
You have put so much effort and experience into your posts and it shows.
Thank you.
M.L.
[...] comprehended that part of the instructions that this became much easier. Also, based on tips from Well Preserved’s awesome series on tomatoes that they’re running this week, I ran the spent pulp through the [...]
Wow, wow and wow – I just found your site yesterday AFTER I’d finished my own bushel of tomatoes (16 jars of salsa, 6 jars of oven dried packed in olive oil, 12 small jars of ketchup and some frozen puree) – I wish I had found it earlier! First off I had no idea how truly big a bushel was (53 lbs?!) and how many tomatoes there were. I felt like I was never ever going to be done. It also explains the state of my hands and why i should have worn gloves!
I am really enjoying your site – I’ve now read a lot of back posts – especially how wonderfully you dealt with the hunting posts. I grew up in northern Ontario before making Toronto my home and you put it all so rationally.
Thanks so much.
[...] wonder, was there a flaw in our technique? I started by adapting Joel’s idea of holding my hand over the output nozzle that spits out the seeds and skins but this seemed to [...]
[...] Catherine are making ceasars right now. 7. We need those cool outdoor propane burners like Well Preserved have. We have one burner on the BBQ that held the big canner and we kept the lids warm on the [...]